The purpose of this assignment is to create an Annotated bibliography for the winter quarter research paper. You should begin by browsing the Katrina Reading list, visiting the library, and using the internet to identify some sources.
After reading a number of sources, compile a bibliography of books and journal articles that you might use to research your topic, format it in the MLA style.
This bibliography must include at least four sources in addition to the textbook(s), and at least two scholarly (peer reviewed journals or books).
Each item in an annotated bibliography (for this class) has the following pieces.
Richard Smith. "Capitalism and Collapse: contradictions of Jared Diamond’s market meliorist strategy to save the humans." Capitalism Nature Socialism Journal. 16.4(December 2005): 19 - 36. Electronic Journal sources at http://www.cnsjournal.org/
A review of Jared Diamonds book Collapse. Basically agrees with most of Diamond's analysis of why societies suceed or fail, but disagrees strongly with Diamond's analysis of the lessons we should learn from this study. Argues that most societies can not choose certain paths because they were controlled by small autocratic groups beyond the control of most of societies members. That this state has much in common with our own world, where big money and corporations are in control, and if we are to avoid the fate of many of these past societies, we will need to exert more control over these entities.
"Diamond’s thesis is that societies such as the Easter Islanders, the Greenland Norse, the Anasazi of the American southwest, the Lowland Mayans and others collapsed largely because they exhausted the natural resources on which they depended and failed to realize the need to change, or, inexplicably, refused to change and instead pursued grim trajectories toward social and economic disintegration and collapse."
"Diamond has opened a fruitful approach to understanding the dynamics of eco-social collapse. Indeed, I think it’s the most important history lesson in his book. But the problem is that when he turns to our modern predicament, he completely forgets his own lesson."
"But we don’t live in a bottom-up democratic society. We live in a capitalist society in which ownership and control of the economy is largely in the hands of private corporations who pursue their own ends and don’t answer to society"
Some advice about formatting and annotating bibliographys can be found at the following web sites. The OWL project (and especially its page about annotated bibliographies), and the liunet website.
As a quide to formatting bibliographic references, I have included the following examples (from the OWL project page).
Thanks to Betsy Natter for ideas on this page.